Baseball is full of statistical oddities, but the St. Louis Cardinals in 2008 and 2009 had one of the strangest name coincidences in franchise history. Enter Brian Barden and Brian Barton.
Both were born in California. Both were born in April. Both were trying to find their footing in the big leagues at the exact same time—often on the same roster.
In this week’s episode of Random Cardinal of the Week, Jim Plaza dives into the overlapping careers of these two players who flashed brilliance before fading into baseball trivia.
In this episode, we discuss:
The 2008 Rule 5 Draft pick that cost the Cardinals a fan favorite (So Taguchi).
Brian Barden’s blistering April 2009 that saw him named NL Rookie of the Month.
The “switch” that happened between the two Brians during Spring Training.
The surprising link between Brian Barden and World Series hero David Freese.
Whether you remember them as the future of the Cardinals’ infield or just as a confusing duo in the box score, we’re breaking down the full “Two Brians” saga. Unfortunately, the quick stay in the majors made it more difficult to find relevant pictures and highlights, so the YouTube video is a little bare on the visual this week. Either way, we hope you have been enjoying this weekly segment and are always welcome to feedback!
Drop your favorite Brian memories below!

